Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 117 guests

Honorverse ramblings and musings

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by The E   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 4:40 pm

The E
Admiral

Posts: 2704
Joined: Tue May 07, 2013 1:28 pm
Location: Meerbusch, Germany

Theemile wrote:They may not be slaves in the manner we are used to thinking. It is quite possible they have a significant degree of free will - within boundaries.

It's those boundaries which are important, and how you create them. It's like the menu your order off of at a restaurant. You don't order lobster bisque at McDonalds - why, it's not on the menu. You take one look and order the Fish Fillet.

If you craft a society where people have sufficient options, perks and freedom within those options, they don't feel like a slave, because they decided to do what they are doing, and go where they are going. They might only have a job choice between sewer cleaner, sewer repair, septic repair, and waste treatment plant, but if you give them the option of a degree in waste management or septic engineering, they suddenly have the option to choose their path and to better themselves if they are able.

And really, how much different is that from how most of us live? we are given options, and we live within them.


And the population of Darius knows for a fact that some people are better at certain jobs than others. I'm guessing they're operating on a quite rigid caste system, and we know that those can be pretty stable (and that's without the kind of provable metrics the Alignment has about the relative performance in certain roles of the various genelines).

cthia wrote:Interesting. Darius has a population equal to Manticore's. If Darius gets into a long protracted war with the GA, I wonder what impact it will have on their population - considering 34 % of their population is a slave pool which they cannot draw from. A reality the US eventually found wasn't feasible.


The whole point of Darius and the Alignment fleet is that they do not engage in major battles, either militarily or politically. That's what the Renaissance Factor is for. I expect the alignment stealth ships to appear as ambushers in support of traditional forces drawn from the RF ranks or as deep scouts. In other words, Darius on its own is not expected to run a fleet as massive as what the Manticorans or Graysons built up, therefore the presence of a caste unsuitable for military service isn't a big deal (and your underlying assumption that the genetic slaves are unsuitable in that way is unproven; I do not recall any textev for it)..
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by Kizarvexis   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 5:22 pm

Kizarvexis
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 270
Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2012 6:18 pm

The E wrote:
Theemile wrote:They may not be slaves in the manner we are used to thinking. It is quite possible they have a significant degree of free will - within boundaries.

It's those boundaries which are important, and how you create them. It's like the menu your order off of at a restaurant. You don't order lobster bisque at McDonalds - why, it's not on the menu. You take one look and order the Fish Fillet.

If you craft a society where people have sufficient options, perks and freedom within those options, they don't feel like a slave, because they decided to do what they are doing, and go where they are going. They might only have a job choice between sewer cleaner, sewer repair, septic repair, and waste treatment plant, but if you give them the option of a degree in waste management or septic engineering, they suddenly have the option to choose their path and to better themselves if they are able.

And really, how much different is that from how most of us live? we are given options, and we live within them.


And the population of Darius knows for a fact that some people are better at certain jobs than others. I'm guessing they're operating on a quite rigid caste system, and we know that those can be pretty stable (and that's without the kind of provable metrics the Alignment has about the relative performance in certain roles of the various genelines).

cthia wrote:Interesting. Darius has a population equal to Manticore's. If Darius gets into a long protracted war with the GA, I wonder what impact it will have on their population - considering 34 % of their population is a slave pool which they cannot draw from. A reality the US eventually found wasn't feasible.


The whole point of Darius and the Alignment fleet is that they do not engage in major battles, either militarily or politically. That's what the Renaissance Factor is for. I expect the alignment stealth ships to appear as ambushers in support of traditional forces drawn from the RF ranks or as deep scouts. In other words, Darius on its own is not expected to run a fleet as massive as what the Manticorans or Graysons built up, therefore the presence of a caste unsuitable for military service isn't a big deal (and your underlying assumption that the genetic slaves are unsuitable in that way is unproven; I do not recall any textev for it)..



I agree, not like the slaves in the rest of the galaxy.

Darius is planning a massive Navy, but maybe with not a good construction infrastructure or innovation.


Mission of Honor wrote:The Mesan Alignment had established the first colony on Gamma almost two hundred T-centuries ago, and it had grown steadily since, although the really exponential growth had begun only over the last seventy T-years or so. Exactly when to begin that particular side of the Alignment's preparations had always been a bit ticklish, since no matter how well it was hidden, there was always the possibility of someone's stubling across it, which could have raised all sorts of questions. On the other hand, the capabilities Darius represented had always been central to the Alignment's strategy, and Albrecht's grandfather had authorized the first colonization flight as one of his last acts as the Alignment's chief executive.
By now, the Darius System's total population was in the very near vicinity of 3.9 billion, of whom just under two billion were representatives of one of the alpha, beta, or gamma genomes the Alignment had worked to improve for so long. The remainder of the system population were genetic slaves, but the conditions of their slavery were very unlike those which obtained elsewhere. For one thing, they were treated far better, without the often savage discipline slaves often received elsewhere. In fact, the Darius System was one of the very few places where the Mesan Constitution's official legal protections theoretically intended to protect slaves from gross mistreatment were actually enforced. For another, they had a much higher standard of living. And for yet another, they formed the backbone of a highly trained, highly skilled labor force which had earned the respect of its supervisors.
Every one of those slaves had been born here in Darius, and not one of them had ever left the system. Their knowledge of what was happening elsewhere in the galaxy, of the history of Mesa, or of their own history had been carefully controlled for generations. They'd been aware for those same generations that they and their parents and grandparents had been laboring to build first the basic industry and then the specialized infrastructure to support a massive navy, but they were convinced it was intended as a defensive fleet.
Yet for all the years which had been plowed into Darius, all the effort, all the generations of labor, the fact remained that its space stations and shipyards were significantly less capable than Manticore's had been prior to Oyster Bay. Benjamin Detweiler didn't like admitting that, but he agreed with his father; the day someone stopped admitting the truth was the day he could kiss any of his hopes for the future goodbye. And the truth was that, despite the accomplishments of the Alignment's R&D, and despite any tactical advantages which might accrue from the streak drive and the spider, very few star nations could have matched the industrial efficiency of the Star Empire of Manticore. Indeed, Benjamin suspected that even Manticore had failed to grasp just how great an advantage it possessed in that regard.
Over the last five or six T-years, he and Daniel had been trying to introduce Manticoran practices here at Darius, only to discover that the task wasn't as simple and forthright as it ought to have been. If they'd really wanted to duplicate Manticore's efficiency, they would've had to duplicate Manticore's entire industrial base—and its society—and they simply couldn't do that. Their labor force was extraordinarily good at following orders, extremely well trained, and highly motivated, but the kind of independence of thought which characterized Manticoran workers wasn't exactly something which had been encouraged among the slave workers of Darius. Even if it had been, their basic techniques and technologies were simply different from Manticore's. Better than the majority of League star systems could have produced, if those other star systems had only realized it, yet still at least a full generation behind the Manties.

Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by saber964   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 5:58 pm

saber964
Admiral

Posts: 2423
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 8:41 pm
Location: Spokane WA USA

cthia wrote:Shadow of Saganami
"And the fourth point is that unlike a great many other middies, you're making your snotty cruise in time of war. It's entirely possible Hexapuma will be called to action while you are on board. You may be wounded. You may be killed. And what is even worse, as I can tell you from personal experience, you may see those you care about—friends or those under your orders—killed or wounded. Accept that now, but don't allow it to prey upon your thoughts or to paralyze you if the moment actually comes. And remember that aboard this ship, you are Queen's officers. You may live, or you may die, but your actions—whatever they may be—will reflect not simply upon you, but upon every man and woman ever called upon to wear the uniform we all wear. See to it that any reflections you cast are the ones for which you want to be remembered . . . because you will be."

When I read this, I immediately thought about the shock that some snotties will suffer in the first battle where they actually see wounded, maimed and dismembered bodies for the first time. I'm thinking... ... with Honorverse tech - holograms and what not - snotties could somewhat be introduced to the overall "feeling" of death and dismemberment via a holographic scene of death lifted right off of battle damaged ships? I wonder if Honorverse tech can simulate the stench of burning flesh?


That is not at all unusual, one of my uncle's joined the USMC right out of HS in 1950. After finishing basic and AIT he was assigned to 1 MarDiv, 3 days before the battle of the Chosen Reservoir began.
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by Weird Harold   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 6:07 pm

Weird Harold
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4478
Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2014 10:25 pm
Location: "Lost Wages", NV

The E wrote:...therefore the presence of a caste unsuitable for military service isn't a big deal (and your underlying assumption that the genetic slaves are unsuitable in that way is unproven; I do not recall any textev for it)..


There isn't any direct textev as to genetic slaves suitability as soldier and sailors, but there is this on their suitability for Manticoran style manufacturing:

Mission of Honor
Chapter Thirty-eight wrote:
Over the last five or six T-years, he and Daniel had been trying to introduce Manticoran practices here at Darius, only to discover that the task wasn't as simple and forthright as it ought to have been. If they'd really wanted to duplicate Manticore's efficiency, they would've had to duplicate Manticore's entire industrial base—and its society—and they simply couldn't do that. Their labor force was extraordinarily good at following orders, extremely well trained, and highly motivated, but the kind of independence of thought which characterized Manticoran workers wasn't exactly something which had been encouraged among the slave workers of Darius. Even if it had been, their basic techniques and technologies were simply different from Manticore's. Better than the majority of League star systems could have produced, if those other star systems had only realized it, yet still at least a full generation behind the Manties.


A slave military would be sort of ineffective without some independence of thought. Sort of like the problem the US had with conscripts in Vietnam.
.
.
.
Answers! I got lots of answers!

(Now if I could just find the right questions.)
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by kzt   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 8:03 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

Weird Harold wrote:A slave military would be sort of ineffective without some independence of thought. Sort of like the problem the US had with conscripts in Vietnam.

Compared to the draftee German military under the Nazis (and their NS Führungsoffizier), which is a society well know for encouraging independent thinking and questioning authority, right?
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by Imaginos1892   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 11:15 pm

Imaginos1892
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1332
Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2012 3:24 pm
Location: San Diego, California, USA

cthia wrote:Shadow of Saganami
"I wouldn't exactly be heartbroken if the Manties suffered a mischief." Anisimovna's tone's mildness fooled no one. "God knows they've been a big enough pain in the ass for as long as I can remember, even leaving aside our recent little misfortunes in Tiberian and Congo. But it's not as if the damned Peeps aren't just as a big a pain."

"For that matter, it was even more Haven than the Manties who engineered the Congo fuck-up," Bardasano said sourly, her smile of a moment before disappearing. The loss of the Congo Wormhole Junction before it could even be adequately surveyed had been almost as upsetting to the Jessyk Combine as the loss of Verdant Vista's slave-breeding facilities and pharmaceutical industry had been to Manpower.

"Agreed," Anisimovna

It seems like the stock in the remaining slaves would shoot up drastically. Law of supply and demand.

And the remaining slaves are probably shuttled around and bartered out to the highest bidder. I wonder what system, or system, has the largest population of slaves?

This suggests that there are still slaver ships running about. And if slaves are becoming the centerpiece of supply and demand then perhaps even Darius imports or exports slaves - a possible weak link in their veil of secrecy?

Slaves were never the point. Manpower, and the whole slave trade, were always just a smokescreen to divert attention away from what the Detweiler Clone Clan was really up to. I'm sure the Alignment took advantage of the situation to perform all sorts of experiments, but now that they have served their purpose they're about as welcome as last week's leftover fish.
--------------------
Philosophy of the Cat: a full belly, a warm bed, and all is right with the world.
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by kzt   » Tue Mar 08, 2016 11:41 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

Weird Harold wrote:
Mission of Honor
Chapter Thirty-eight wrote:
Over the last five or six T-years, he and Daniel had been trying to introduce Manticoran practices here at Darius, only to discover that the task wasn't as simple and forthright as it ought to have been. If they'd really wanted to duplicate Manticore's efficiency, they would've had to duplicate Manticore's entire industrial base—and its society—and they simply couldn't do that. Their labor force was extraordinarily good at following orders, extremely well trained, and highly motivated, but the kind of independence of thought which characterized Manticoran workers wasn't exactly something which had been encouraged among the slave workers of Darius. Even if it had been, their basic techniques and technologies were simply different from Manticore's. Better than the majority of League star systems could have produced, if those other star systems had only realized it, yet still at least a full generation behind the Manties.


David has some odd ideas about economics. For example, when you think of German, Swiss or Japanese society do you think of "independence of thought"? Would you consider German machine tools to be inferior to those from Spain or Scotland? Would you prefer to have a $2500 Japanese camera or a $2500 Mexican camera?
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by cthia   » Wed Mar 09, 2016 4:16 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

Weird Harold wrote:
The E wrote:...therefore the presence of a caste unsuitable for military service isn't a big deal (and your underlying assumption that the genetic slaves are unsuitable in that way is unproven; I do not recall any textev for it)..


There isn't any direct textev as to genetic slaves suitability as soldier and sailors, but there is this on their suitability for Manticoran style manufacturing:

Mission of Honor
Chapter Thirty-eight wrote:
Over the last five or six T-years, he and Daniel had been trying to introduce Manticoran practices here at Darius, only to discover that the task wasn't as simple and forthright as it ought to have been. If they'd really wanted to duplicate Manticore's efficiency, they would've had to duplicate Manticore's entire industrial base—and its society—and they simply couldn't do that. Their labor force was extraordinarily good at following orders, extremely well trained, and highly motivated, but the kind of independence of thought which characterized Manticoran workers wasn't exactly something which had been encouraged among the slave workers of Darius. Even if it had been, their basic techniques and technologies were simply different from Manticore's. Better than the majority of League star systems could have produced, if those other star systems had only realized it, yet still at least a full generation behind the Manties.


A slave military would be sort of ineffective without some independence of thought. Sort of like the problem the US had with conscripts in Vietnam.


****** *

I didn't mean ineligible because of any inadequate military training - though all kinds of red flags should be raised there. But ineligible because the scope of Darius and Detweiler's plan and any loyalty to it and the navy, I surmise, will not be first and foremost in a slave.

Would you consider a slave to be loyal to its navy? To die before giving secrets? I don't. Being kept far outside of the onion is also being kept far outside any emotional attachment to it - outside of the "brotherhood of the onion." I don't imagine the MAlign would want the GA to capture a bunch of slaves.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by kzt   » Wed Mar 09, 2016 4:31 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

cthia wrote:Would you consider a slave to be loyal to its navy? To die before giving secrets? I don't. Being kept far outside of the onion is also being kept far outside any emotional attachment to it - outside of the "brotherhood of the onion." I don't imagine the MAlign would want the GA to capture a bunch of slaves.

The fact that you don't see how this can work doesn't mean it doesn't actually work in practice. For example, the Janissaries were quite effective as troops for the Ottoman's for nearly 500 years. The Mamluk existed for quite a bit longer. There were certain "issues" that arose under weak governments, but as the history of the Praetorian Guard shows, this isn't limited to slave soldiers.
Top
Re: Honorverse ramblings and musings
Post by cthia   » Wed Mar 09, 2016 4:32 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

You know what struck me (other than the objects a wife throws lol), I've had many heroes of a sort killed off. Superman died and was brought back in the comic book world. We have our own fan in 'HonorWorld', Joe Buckley, that evades death. It isn't that some have been killed off inasmuch as how the illustrious author chooses to bring them back - to offer something plausible as to why they are still breathing.

So I'm thinking. What if David killed off Honor, and later saw the error of his ways. How would he choose to bring her back, if he decided? Then I realized that he has done that already - Cerberus. And I actually like the way he brought her back. Yet we as readers knew she was alive.

What if RFC had killed her off 'for keeps' in his readers' eyes then decided to revive her? I wonder what that would be like.

Apologies for my wandering err rambling mind out loud.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top

Return to Honorverse